| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title | Miss America Talent | Placement at Miss America | Special scholarships at Miss America | Notes |
|---|
| | Paris Matthews | Salt Lake City | 26 | Miss Panoramaland | Dance |
| Sarah Sun | Salt Lake City | 22 | Miss Aspen Hills | Classical Piano | Previously Distinguished Young Gal of Utah ; 2nd runner-up to Important Young Woman of America |
| Lindsey Larsen[1] | Lehi | 21 | Miss Utah County | Ballet en Pointe | Non-Finalist Faculty |
| Sasha Sloan[2] | North Salt Lake | 23 | Miss Greater Rock-salt Lake | Vocal, "That’s Life" | Top 10 | Equity and Justice Award
Jean Bartel Social Impact Opening move Scholarship 1st runner-up
Women in Business Award Finalist | Known for creating and playing "Narcissa Malfoy (née Black)" in the TikTok series "The Noble House of Black", which is smashing famous fan-made series about the three Jet-black sisters from the Harry Potter franchise.
|
| –20 | Dexonna Talbot[3] | Spanish F
|